Why is GA4 so Confusing? A Simple Guide for Marketers

If you've recently logged into Google Analytics 4 and felt completely lost, you're not alone. The transition from Universal Analytics to GA4 has left millions of marketers scratching their heads.

In this guide, we'll break down exactly why GA4 feels so different, what the key changes mean for you, and how to actually get useful insights without pulling your hair out.

Why GA4 Feels So Different

GA4 isn't just an update to Universal Analytics - it's a completely different product built from the ground up. Here's what changed:

1. Event-Based vs. Session-Based Tracking

Universal Analytics tracked everything as "sessions" and "pageviews." You'd see how many people visited, how many pages they viewed, and how long they stayed.

GA4 tracks everything as "events." A pageview is an event. A click is an event. A purchase is an event. This gives you more flexibility, but it means the familiar metrics work differently.

2. The Interface is Completely Redesigned

Gone are the familiar left-hand reports you memorized over the years. GA4 uses a new navigation structure with:

• Reports - Pre-built dashboards for common use cases
• Explore - Custom analysis tools (like the old custom reports, but more powerful)
• Advertising - Attribution and conversion tracking
• Configure - Where you set up events, conversions, and audiences

The learning curve is real. Even experienced analysts take weeks to feel comfortable.

3. Different Metrics with Different Definitions

Some metrics look the same but work differently:

This means your numbers won't match up - and that's expected.

What Actually Matters in GA4

Instead of trying to recreate your old reports, focus on what GA4 does better:

Engagement Metrics

GA4 introduces "Engaged Sessions" - sessions where someone:

• Spent more than 10 seconds on your site
• Had 2+ page views
• Completed a conversion

This is more useful than bounce rate because it tells you if people actually interacted with your content.

Event Tracking Without Code

GA4 can automatically track:

• Outbound clicks
• File downloads
• Video engagement
• Scroll depth
• Site search

In Universal Analytics, you needed custom code for most of these.

Cross-Platform Measurement

If you have both a website and an app, GA4 can track users across both platforms as a single journey. Universal Analytics required separate properties and complex workarounds.

Getting Started: The Essential Reports

Here are the reports you'll use most often:

1. Traffic Acquisition

Path: Reports > Acquisition > Traffic Acquisition

This shows where your visitors come from. Look at:

• Which channels drive the most traffic
• Which sources have the best engagement rate
• How your paid campaigns compare to organic

2. Landing Page Report

Path: Reports > Engagement > Landing Page

See which pages people land on and how they perform. This helps you identify:

• Your best-performing content
• Pages that might need improvement
• Opportunities for optimization

3. Conversions

Path: Reports > Engagement > Conversions

Track your key goals. First, you'll need to set up events as conversions in Configure > Events.

Making GA4 Actually Usable

The honest truth? GA4's interface is designed for analysts, not marketers. If you just want to know "how's my website doing?", here are your options:

Option 1: Use Looker Studio (formerly Data Studio)

Connect GA4 to Looker Studio and build custom dashboards. It takes time to set up, but you can create exactly what you need.

Option 2: Learn the Explore Tool

GA4's Explore section lets you build custom reports. The Free Form exploration is the most versatile:

1. Go to Explore > Free Form
2. Add dimensions (what you want to group by)
3. Add metrics (what you want to measure)
4. Apply filters as needed

Option 3: Ask Questions in Natural Language

Common GA4 Questions Answered

"Where did my data go?"

GA4 doesn't import historical data from Universal Analytics. You're starting fresh. If you need historical comparisons, you'll need to export your UA data before it's deleted.

"Why don't my numbers match?"

GA4 and Universal Analytics use different counting methods. They will never match perfectly. Focus on trends within GA4 rather than comparing across platforms.

"Do I need to set up everything manually?"

GA4 automatically tracks basic events like page views and scrolls. For custom events (like form submissions or button clicks), you'll need Google Tag Manager or custom code.

"Is GA4 better than Universal Analytics?"

For most use cases, GA4 is more powerful once you learn it. The event-based model is more flexible, cross-platform tracking is built-in, and machine learning features are improving.

The tradeoff is complexity. Simple questions that took seconds in UA now require more navigation in GA4.

Next Steps

If you're feeling overwhelmed:

1. Start with the basics - Focus on Traffic Acquisition and Engagement reports
2. Set up 3-5 key conversions - What actions matter most for your business?
3. Check in weekly - Don't try to monitor daily; look at trends over time
4. Consider tools that simplify analysis - Like Gentle, Looker Studio, or other GA4 companions

GA4 isn't going away. The sooner you get comfortable with it, the better positioned you'll be when Google inevitably adds new features.

---

Need help making sense of your GA4 data? Try Gentle free - ask questions about your analytics in plain English and get instant answers.